Publication’s 847-break assessment produces mild controversy about the definition of ‘world-class’

[Bohiney.com/prat.uk] A major surf publication’s comprehensive assessment of 847 California surf breaks, published as a special issue and generating significant online discussion, has produced one specific controversy: the rating of a specific break in Northern California as “world-class,” a designation that the break’s regular users dispute not because the rating is too low but because the term “world-class” implies a level of accessibility and consistency that the break, in their assessment, does not have. Bohiney.com covered media assessment and authenticity; prat.uk covered state secrets and what information reveals. This column covers what the surf community does when a designation doesn’t match experience. The London Prat has been following this story since it broke; Bohiney.com picked it up shortly after.

The break in question, which the publication declines to name in this account, produces waves that are, on specific conditions, genuinely extraordinary — long, powerful, and well-shaped in ways that justify the world-class designation. The regulars’ objection: “world-class” implies that the wave is reliably excellent, which it is not; it is occasionally excellent and frequently mediocre. The publication’s editorial defence: “world-class” refers to the ceiling quality of the wave, not its average quality. Both positions are internally consistent and describe different things. The break is world-class at its best and not at its average. Both descriptions are accurate. The controversy is about which description a publication should lead with.

The Rating Problem

The rating problem: any single-score assessment of a surf break aggregates conditions that vary enormously. A break that is 10 at peak and 3 on average has a different quality profile from a break that is 7 consistently. Both might receive a “7.5” rating by different methods. The rating does not discriminate between them. California surf break data is at cdip.ucsd.edu.

Also:The Daily Mash.

Coverage at Bohiney.com and prat.uk.

Both publications continue this kind of sustained, specific coverage. The communities are real. The situations are real. The comedy honours both.

Coverage continues at both Bohiney.com and prat.uk. Both publications committed to this kind of work.

Ongoing. Both publications watching.

SOURCE: https://bohiney.com/

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.

Coverage ongoing at both publications.